Jury awards Iowa woman $19.8 million for “botched” Mayo Clinic surgery

Jury awards Iowa woman $19.8 million for “botched” Mayo Clinic surgery

Stephen Swanson | CBS NEWS | November 26, 2025

A jury has awarded an Iowa woman a $19.8 million verdict against Mayo Clinic and a colorectal surgeon in a lawsuit brought in Minnesota courts, according to her attorneys.

The Iowa-based Hixson & Brown Law Firm represented patient Linette Nelson, of Fort Dodge, Iowa. They alleged in a June 2018 procedure — the second in a series of three surgeries — Dr. Amy Lightner was supposed to move her entire rectum, but “botched a multi-stage operation” and “left 5-7 cm of diseased rectum inside her body.”

The suit alleged Lightner dismissed a CT scan that showed “a long rectal cuff” remained inside Nelson and “pushed ahead with the third surgery anyway,” according to attorneys.

A month later, Nelson was informed by Mayo that Lightner “is gone and we’re not sure if she’ll be back,” according to the law firm. The chief of colorectal surgery for Mayo, Dr. David Larson, then examined her and determined the surgeries needed to be redone, a process that took more than a year to complete.

The firm said the actions of Lightner, who now works in California, “left [Nelson] with permanent disfigurement, pelvic floor disorder, fibromyalgia, PTSD, and lifelong chronic pain.”

Court records show the verdict includes $3.7 million for pain and emotional distress, with another $12.1 million for her future emotional distress. The law firm said the monetary award for Nelson, a mother of two, “is expected to exceed $27 million” when adding in interest.

“The jury’s verdict speaks truth and justice: world-class reputations don’t excuse life-altering medical negligence,” said attorney LaMar Jost. “This verdict is a step toward accountability for a wife and mother who will suffer for the rest of her life because of medical negligence.”

A Mayo Clinic spokesperson gave this statement to WCCO on Wednesday morning: “Mayo Clinic respects the jury’s time and the judicial process, but is disappointed in the verdict. The organization will evaluate next steps while remaining steadfast in its commitment to providing the highest standards of care and patient outcomes.”

U.S. News and World Report recently named Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, as one of the best hospitals in the country, and also named it the best hospital for diabetes, endocrinology, gastroenterology, and GI surgery.

Read the entire article at CBS NEWS.

Jury awards nearly $20 million for ‘botched’ Mayo surgery

Jury awards nearly $20 million for ‘botched’ Mayo surgery

Jeremy Olson | The Minnesota Star Tribune | November 26, 2025
An Olmsted County jury awarded $19.8 million to an Iowa mother who suffered abdominal disfigurement and ongoing pain after a “botched” surgery at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, a law firm announced Wednesday.
Attorneys representing Linette Nelson said the judgment compensates for a string of mistakes at Mayo, which started in 2018 during a complex, three-stage colorectal procedure when Dr. Amy Lightner left diseased tissue inside her patient.
Nelson, a mother of two who lives in Fort Dodge, Iowa, faces a lifetime of medical monitoring and possibly more corrective surgeries as a result of the error, her attorneys said.
“World-class reputations don’t excuse life-altering medical negligence,” said LaMar Jost, one of Nelson’s attorneys at the Hixson & Brown Law Firm in West Des Moines.
The lead surgeon in the case has left Mayo and now practices in California. A statement from a Mayo spokesperson said the health system’s leaders are “disappointed in the verdict. The organization will evaluate next steps while remaining steadfast in its commitment to providing the highest standards of care and patient outcomes.”
The size of the award was unusual but not unprecedented. A Wisconsin jury awarded more than $13 million in 2023 to a woman who suffered a stroke during a cardiac procedure at the Mayo Clinic Health System hospital in Eau Claire.
The record medical malpractice verdict in Minnesota occurred in 2022, when a federal jury awarded $110 million for negligent care by an orthopedic practice in St. Paul to a patient who suffered a soccer injury. A judge later reduced that award to $10 million.
Monday’s verdict followed a nine-day jury trial over the treatment of Nelson, who sought surgery at Mayo because other treatments had failed to address ulcerative colitis — an inflammation that causes pain and digestive problems.
The surgery, in three stages, was supposed to remove diseased sections of Nelson’s intestine and rectum, create a temporary lower digestive tract while she healed, and then finally stitch together the remaining healthy sections of her colon.
Problems emerged when more than 5 centimeters of diseased tissue were left behind during the second procedure, and then when Lightner overlooked imaging data about the error and pressed on with the third procedure, court records show.
Another doctor had to redo the entire surgery, which was complicated by the damage from the first attempt, according to Nelson’s attorneys.

Read the entire article at The Minnesota Star Tribune.

Iowa woman awarded nearly $20M in Mayo Clinic malpractice case

Iowa woman awarded nearly $20M in Mayo Clinic malpractice case

KAALTV | November 27, 2025

(ABC 6 News) – An Iowa woman was awarded nearly $19 million in damages in a medical malpractice suit against Mayo Clinic Rochester.

According to court documents, Fort Dodge, IA resident Linette Nelson accused former Mayo doctor Amy Lightner and Mayo Clinic of botching two several surgeries in 2017 and 2018.

According to court documents, instead of a planned three surgeries, Nelson required five in total — two of which were by a new physician, after Nelson complained of significant pain and issues and Lightner left Mayo.

Court documents further alleged that Lightner had been negligent in telling Nelson that images showing Lightner’s failure to complete the first surgery were incorrect, and that Lightner ignored information or refused to perform exams that would have shown the problems to be real.

Lightner no longer works at Mayo Clinic’s Rochester campus.

On Nov. 24, a jury provided Linette Nelson with $15.8 million in compensation, and her spouse, Daniel Nelson, with $4 million.

Read the entire article at ABC 6 News

John Choi

John Choi

John Choi

John Choie
BAR ADMISSIONS

Hawaii
Hawaii Federal District Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

 

PREVIOUSLY ADMITTED PRO-HAC VICE

California

Education

Gerry Spence Trial Lawyer’s College

Vermont Law School
– MSEL Master of Science Environmental Law
-J.D. Juris Doctor

University of California Irvine
-B.A. Social Ecology with emphasis in criminal justice

Bio

John Choi

John is an experienced trial lawyer. Prior to practicing law, he was the executive director of a non-profit. He was raised by an engineer dad and a pharmacist mom who instilled in him precision, accuracy, and determination. In his extended family, there are four M.D.s, three dentists, many engineers, as many veterans, and entrepreneurs. He proudly presents as the only lawyer.

John’s primary focus is representing injured people, but he enjoys filing lawsuits against insurance companies. He has a record-breaking three-day trial in which the jury awarded millions against a national insurance company for its failure to pay a valid claim. John called Nick from the courthouse steps to thank him and attributes his big verdict to Nick.

Having worked in the government as a Deputy Attorney General, John tried many cases, and one of his appeals was published in a Hawaii Supreme Court opinion dealing with the constitutional issue of the separation of powers between the executive branch and the judicial branch of government.

After leaving the government, John’s first jury trial win was in a criminal grand theft auto case involving a repeat offender. The client fired her public defender, who was trying to get her to plea bargain. She told John that her first two convictions were the same – the public defender talked her out of going to trial and had struck a plea deal. They went to trial and won! John exposed the government’s conflicting trial testimony that revealed the truck owner’s son had lost the truck in a poker game and never told his dad who had reported it stolen. You can’t make this stuff up. They were going to put this lady in jail for 10 years on a false charge. The truck was never stolen.

John was awarded Teacher of the Year at the Princeton Review, his first job out of college. While at UC Irvine, he was inducted into the Order of Omega. In law school, he was selected for the joint degree environmental law program. John also wrote for the Vermont Bar Journal.

While in law school, he was a summer intern at the Hawaii State Attorney General’s Office, where he worked for Larry Lau and Brian Yee, two iconic figures. There, he helped on a Clean Water Act case and with matters dealing with Public Utilities. In Hawaii, John has been a chapter president of the Hawaii Jaycees, Hawaii Christian Legal Society, and currently serves on the Board of Directors for the Hawaii Association for Justice.

He also represented Hawaii counties in the opioid litigation together with a team of premier lawyers against Big Pharmaceutical companies in a historic $78 million statewide settlement.

John also represents indigent clients pro bono. An 80-year-old grandmother was injured on the city bus, and he represented the grandmother pro bono without a fee.

Away from the courtroom, John enjoys his family time in the ocean, on the golf course, or in the kitchen. He and Michelle have been married for over 25 years. They have two daughters, one in college who competes in NCAA golf tournaments and another still in high school. They also raise a rescue dog from Kauai, a rare barkless Chihuahua. They also enjoy two laying hens, a Legbar and a White Crested Polish.

John speaks Hawaiian Pidgin, Korean, and Spanish.

Tom Dickerson

Tom Dickerson

Tom Dickerson

Tom Dickerson
BAR ADMISSIONS

Kansas
Missouri
United States District Court, District of Kansas
United States District Court, Western District of Missouri
United States Court of Appeals, 10th Circuit

 

EDUCATION

University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas,
B.A. Political Science

Creighton University School of Law
– Omaha, Nebraska, J.D.

Bio

Tom Dickerson

Thomas J. Dickerson is a passionate Kansas City personal injury lawyer and advocate with a strong moral compass. Tom believes in the importance of standing up for individual people and their families against wrongdoers and the insurance companies that defend this wrongful conduct. Tom routinely takes this battle into the courtroom and has tried a significant number of trials, including personal injury trials on transportation collisions, construction zone accidents, boating accidents, premises liabilitymedical malpracticedog bites, property damage, and consumer protection matters.

Tom was born in St. Louis, Missouri and raised in Overland Park, Kansas. Tom started doing legal work when he was only 19 years old, working for the head of litigation at a mid-size firm that defended large financial institutions. In that position, Tom obtained invaluable experience seeing how some of the largest corporations in the country approached legal cases against everyday people. After seeing numerous cases where everyday people faced insurmountable odds against big business, Mr. Dickerson decided to dedicate his career to standing up for regular, hard-working people and their families. He fights to protect their rights and helps them obtain justice and fair compensation for their injuries and damages suffered due to the negligence of others. Tom started the Dickerson Oxton Law Firm with Chelsea Oxton Dickerson in 2010.

Tom has extensive experience in motor vehicle accidents, medical malpractice and nursing home negligence, catastrophic injuries, wrongful death, dog bites, job-related injuries, insurance disputes, and consumer protection matters.