866-TL4J-LAW (866-854-5529)           Billions of Dollars in Victories

TL4J On CVN’s Top 10 Most Impressive Plaintiff Verdicts of 2021

#8 – Castillo v. Davignon

$9.5m award over child’s crosswalk death beats out $1.2m settlement offer

Plaintiff attorneys: Nicholas Rowley (pictured), Benjamin Novotny – Trial Lawyers For Justice, Charlotte Glinka, Karen Zahka – Keches Law Group

Castillo closings

Link to video of the full trial:


Why it made the list:

A Massachusetts state court jury awarded $9.5 million in damages on Friday to the two adult children of a woman struck and killed by a truck while walking her dog in 2017.

Attorneys for defendant Charles Davignon, who drove the truck that struck Rosenthal, conceded that he was liable for her death. That left the jury tasked solely with determining how much to compensate Rosenthal’s children for the death of their mother, a teacher who was 52 at the time of the accident.

“For the last three years, the defendant refused to take responsibility for their mother’s death,” plaintiff’s attorney Nicholas Rowley of  Trial Lawyers for Justice said in a statement released after the verdict. “That changed during this trial. This trial was necessary because the insurance company acted irresponsibly and cheaply. Now they’ll have to face the consequences.”

Read the whole article here:


Get a Free Evaluation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Nick Rowley Interviewed About The Destiny Reyes Case

Nick Rowley, trial lawyer for little Destiny Reyes, speaks on camera about Destiny Reyes, a young girl who was injured in a car accident, and how he and his trial team stepped…

Trial Lawyers for Justice Settles Record $3.5 Million Case Against State of Iowa

Trial Lawyer Nick Rowley, partner at Carpenter, Zuckerman, & Rowley and founder of Trial Lawyers for Justice, his partners at Trial Lawyers for Justice, Dominic Pechota and Matt Reilly

Hospital shutoff oxygen leading to death

It had been a rough week, but David Hackley's family was looking forward to finally bringing him home. Hackley, 77,...

Nation State of Play Podcast featuring Nicholas Rowley on California’s Regressive Malpractice Damages Cap

The complete settlement is more than $9.5 million in the case of the late Zoe Rosenthal, a popular teacher with The Literacy Project.